Grade accuracy ledger
How often GradeThread grades are challenged, and how often they change. Judge the grade the way you would judge any grader: by its record. Every figure below shows how many cases it rests on and the date it runs to.
By quarter
Loading the ledger...
Method
- Grades certified
- Grades issued a certificate in the quarter.
- Disputes filed and upheld
- A dispute counts in the quarter it was filed. It is decided once a reviewer resolves or rejects it. It is upheld only when the reviewer changed the grade. A dispute closed with the grade left as it was is decided, not upheld.
- Average correction
- For upheld disputes, the average number of points the grade moved, up or down. The starting point is the certified grade as it stood when the reviewer acted.
- Guarantee claims approved
- Claims that an item was not as graded, counted in the quarter they were filed, across both kinds of guarantee claim GradeThread takes. Approved includes paid and automatically approved claims.
- Blind spot-check agreement
- A small random share of grades that went live with no person checking them is scored again by a reviewer who cannot see the AI grade. The AI side is the grade that went live; the human side is the reviewer's blind score. They agree when they are within 0.5 points. A spot check never changes the published grade.
- What is left out
- Send-backs, where a reviewer returns a grade because the photos cannot support one, are not counted anywhere on this page. They say nothing about whether the grade was right. Spot checks a reviewer picked on purpose because the grade looked hard are left out of the agreement rate, which covers the random ones only. Authenticity appeals are not grade disputes and are not counted as disputes.
- Small samples
- Counts are shown at any size, so a real zero reads 0. The average correction and the agreement rate need at least 30 cases in the quarter; below that they read Unavailable with the count so far. A figure whose data could not be read also reads Unavailable, never 0.
For accuracy against expert reviewers across all reviewed grades, see the transparency report.
Ready to Grade Smarter?
Join resellers who trust GradeThread to standardize condition grading, build buyer confidence, and sell faster.
Start Grading Free