# Grading a used dress shirt

> How to grade a used dress shirt: collar and cuff fraying, ring stains, and buttons, plus a photo checklist and graded examples on the 1–10 scale.

Grading a used dress shirt turns on the collar and cuffs. These are the first areas to fray and stain, so the grade leads with collar-edge wear, cuff fraying, and the ring stains that thin cotton picks up — then checks the buttons, placket, and any yellowing from long storage.

## What to check

- Collar-edge and cuff fraying — the first areas to wear
- Ring-around-the-collar staining and underarm yellowing
- Button count, cracks, and secure attachment
- Overall whiteness vs. storage yellowing

## How to grade it, step by step

1. Inspect the collar and cuffs
   Run a finger along the collar fold and cuff edges for fraying and thin spots. Frayed edges are the most common dress-shirt flaw and lead the grade.
2. Check for staining
   Look for ring stains at the collar, yellowing under the arms, and food or ink marks on the front. Set stains cap the grade.
3. Count and test buttons
   Confirm every button is present, uncracked, and firmly sewn, and note any missing or mismatched replacements.

## Graded examples

| Grade | Why |
| --- | --- |
| 9 (NWOT) | Crisp collar, bright white, all buttons intact. |
| 6 (Good) | Light collar wear, all buttons present, no stains. |
| 3 (Poor) | Frayed collar edge, underarm yellowing, one missing button. |

Every grade sits on the [GradeThread 1.0–10.0 scale](https://gradethread.com/grading/scale).

## Flaws to watch on this garment

[Fabric thinning](https://gradethread.com/care/fabric-thinning)[Missing buttons](https://gradethread.com/care/missing-buttons)[Pit stains](https://gradethread.com/care/pit-stains)

## Frequently asked

### What's the first thing that lowers a dress shirt's grade?

Collar and cuff wear. Because these edges fold and rub constantly, they fray and thin before the rest of the shirt shows any age. A frayed collar edge is usually the flaw that moves a dress shirt from very good down into the good-or-below range.

[Grade an item free](https://gradethread.com/signup)

## Ready to Grade Smarter?

Join resellers who trust GradeThread to standardize condition grading, build buyer confidence, and sell faster.

[Start Grading Free](https://gradethread.com/signup)

Shopping for a dress shirt? The GradeThread extension reads the condition from the listing's photos, on the marketplace you are already on.

[Add to Chrome](https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/apinefjjagmigmobdlbiilhbjebmjkdh)

---

Canonical: [https://gradethread.com/grading/guides/dress-shirt](https://gradethread.com/grading/guides/dress-shirt)

Last updated: 2026-06-01

Source: GradeThread (gradethread.com). Please cite and link the canonical page.
