# Grading a used cardigan

> How to grade a used cardigan: placket buttons, buttonhole stretch, pilling, and ribbing, with graded examples on the 1–10 condition scale.

Grading a used cardigan blends knitwear checks with a button placket. The grade leads with pilling and shape recovery like any knit, then adds the front-specific flaws — placket buttons present and matching, buttonhole stretch, and a placket that hangs straight rather than gaping or drooping from wear.

## What to check

- Placket buttons present, matching, and secure
- Buttonhole stretch and a straight-hanging front
- Pilling at underarms, cuffs, and sides
- Ribbing recovery at cuffs, hem, and front band

## How to grade it, step by step

1. Work the placket
   Button the cardigan and check that the front hangs straight, buttons match, and buttonholes aren't stretched open — the flaws unique to a cardigan.
2. Grade the knit
   Scan for pilling at the underarms and cuffs and note whether it lifts off or has matted in.
3. Test the ribbing
   Stretch and release the cuffs, hem, and front band; a stretched, drooping band lowers the grade.

## Graded examples

| Grade | Why |
| --- | --- |
| 9 (NWOT) | Straight placket, all buttons matching, no pilling. |
| 6 (Good) | Light cuff pilling, buttons intact, band holds. |
| 3 (Poor) | Two missing buttons and stretched, gaping buttonholes. |

Every grade sits on the [GradeThread 1.0–10.0 scale](https://gradethread.com/grading/scale).

## Flaws to watch on this garment

[Pilling](https://gradethread.com/care/pilling)[Missing buttons](https://gradethread.com/care/missing-buttons)[Stretching](https://gradethread.com/care/stretching)

## Frequently asked

### Do mismatched replacement buttons lower a cardigan's grade?

Yes, modestly. Replacement buttons that don't match the originals are visible and read as a repair, so they nudge the grade down even when they're secure. A full set of original, matching buttons is part of a high-grade cardigan; odd or plastic swaps on a wool piece are a clear flaw.

[Grade an item free](https://gradethread.com/signup)

## Ready to Grade Smarter?

Join resellers who trust GradeThread to standardize condition grading, build buyer confidence, and sell faster.

[Start Grading Free](https://gradethread.com/signup)

Shopping for a cardigan? The GradeThread extension reads the condition from the listing's photos, on the marketplace you are already on.

[Add to Chrome](https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/apinefjjagmigmobdlbiilhbjebmjkdh)

---

Canonical: [https://gradethread.com/grading/guides/cardigan](https://gradethread.com/grading/guides/cardigan)

Last updated: 2026-06-01

Source: GradeThread (gradethread.com). Please cite and link the canonical page.
